Healthcare fraud is a complex issue that has become increasingly scrutinized in recent years, with hospitals and healthcare professionals often finding themselves at the center of accusations and large government investigations.
So, exactly what is healthcare fraud? Fraud in healthcare, in its simplest form, involves either patients or medical providers deliberately submitting false claims or misrepresenting information to obtain unauthorized benefits from health insurance programs or government healthcare initiatives.
In this article, the healthcare fraud attorneys from Sellers Law Firm will discuss the different types of healthcare fraud and how individuals can protect themselves from false allegations, implement robust compliance programs, and maintain their integrity in an increasingly scrutinized environment.
Understanding healthcare fraud in depth
Healthcare fraud encompasses a wide range of deceptive practices that exploit the healthcare system for financial gain. While the basic definition given by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) involves deliberately submitting false claims or misrepresenting information, the ways in which healthcare fraud can manifest are often diverse, sometimes subtle, and can even be accidental.
It’s crucial to understand that healthcare fraud isn’t limited to a single group; it can be committed by various actors within the healthcare ecosystem. Hospitals, individual physicians, nurses, pharmacists, and other healthcare providers can all potentially engage in fraudulent activities.
Patients, insurance companies, and even third-party billing companies have been implicated in fraud schemes. Pharmaceutical companies have faced accusations of fraud related to drug pricing, marketing practices, or clinical trial data manipulation. Each of these entities might employ different tactics, but the common thread is the intentional deception for financial benefit at the expense of the healthcare system and, ultimately, other patients and taxpayers.
Types of healthcare fraud
For hospitals and healthcare providers, being accused of fraud can have devastating effects. Beyond potential legal consequences, which can include hefty fines and criminal charges, there’s also significant reputational damage — even if there is no conviction.
Here are the types of healthcare fraud to be aware of:
- Billing for services not rendered: This is one of the most straightforward forms of fraud. It involves charging for medical services or procedures that were never actually performed.
- Upcoding: This occurs when a healthcare provider bills for a more expensive service or procedure than what was actually performed. For example, billing for a comprehensive examination when only a brief consultation took place.
- Unbundling: This involves billing separately for procedures that are typically billed together at a lower rate. By unbundling, the total charge becomes higher than it should be.
- Kickbacks: This refers to healthcare providers receiving payment for patient referrals, which is illegal under the Anti-Kickback Statute.
- Stark Law violations: This involves physicians referring patients to entities with which they have a financial relationship, which is prohibited in certain circumstances. (Learn about the difference between Stark Law vs. Anti-Kickback Statute)
- False certification: This occurs when a provider falsely certifies that certain medical conditions exist to justify tests, surgeries, or other procedures.
- Phantom billing: Similar to billing for services not rendered, this involves billing for fake patients or deceased individuals.
- Medicare fraud or Medicaid fraud: This might involve billing for services not medically necessary, misrepresenting a patient’s diagnosis to justify certain services, knowingly billing for services at a level of complexity higher than services actually provided, or enrolling ineligible individuals in Medicaid or Medicare plans. Medicaid or Medicare fraud can also include prescription drug fraud, where medications are unlawfully prescribed or billed to Medicaid/Medicare.
It’s important to note that not all of these errors constitute fraud. The key element in healthcare fraud is intent. Accidental miscoding or honest mistakes in billing, while problematic, are not considered fraud unless there’s evidence of deliberate deception.
What are examples of healthcare fraud?
Healthcare fraud can manifest in various ways. Here are some specific healthcare fraud examples, including a few examples of the types of fraud we just discussed:
- Phantom billing: A clinic bills Medicare for 100 patient visits on a day when the clinic was actually closed due to a power outage.
- Upcoding: A doctor performs a simple 15-minute check-up but bills it as a comprehensive 40-minute examination.
- Unbundling: A hospital separates charges for a surgical procedure, anesthesia, and recovery room use when these should be billed as a single, lower-cost package.
- Services not rendered: A home health agency bills for daily nurse visits to a patient who was actually in the hospital during that time.
- Kickbacks: A physician receives payments from a pharmaceutical company for prescribing their medication over equally effective, less expensive alternatives.
- Medicare fraud: A durable medical equipment supplier bills Medicare for expensive motorized wheelchairs when they can provide much cheaper standard wheelchairs.
- False certification: A doctor falsely certifies that a patient needs home health services to continue billing for unnecessary care.
- Identity theft: A fraudster uses stolen patient information to bill for fake medical services.
- Prescription drug fraud: A pharmacist fills prescriptions with generic drugs but bills for more expensive brand-name medications.
- Stark Law violations: A physician refers patients for MRI scans to a facility where they have a financial interest, without disclosing this relationship.
- Unnecessary procedures: A dentist performs and bills for unneeded root canals on patients with healthy teeth.
- Misrepresenting credentials: A clinic employs an unlicensed individual but bills their services as if performed by a licensed professional.
These examples illustrate the diverse nature of healthcare fraud, ranging from simple medical billing fraud and lack of medical necessity to complex schemes involving multiple parties. It’s important to note that healthcare providers and institutions should have robust compliance programs to prevent, detect, and address such fraudulent activities.
Facing allegations of healthcare fraud? Contact Sellers Law Firm immediately.
Now you know that healthcare fraud is complex, evolving, and contains a laundry list of deceptive practices that exploit the healthcare system and its participants for unlawful financial gain.
Given the intricacies of healthcare regulations and the severe consequences of fraud allegations, healthcare practices and professionals facing criminal charges need to hire experienced Fort Worth healthcare fraud lawyers, like those from Sellers Law Firm, and fast.
Our firm has experience offering everything from medical billing fraud defense to anti-kickback defense. We understand the nuances of healthcare law and can help you implement strong compliance programs, respond to investigations, and defend against fraud accusations.
Don’t wait until you’re facing allegations to seek legal advice. Proactive legal counsel can help protect your practice and your reputation. Schedule a free online consultation today to ensure your healthcare practice is properly safeguarded against the risks of healthcare fraud allegations.
More Helpful Articles by Sellers Law Firm:
- What Can Cause Permanent Disability After a Car Accident?
- Most Common White Collar Crimes & Defense Strategies
- What is Racketeering?
- Texas Knife Laws: Can You Pull a Knife on Someone?
- How to Get a Drug Trafficking Charge Dismissed
